16 November 2026 · By Ike Kennedy, co-founder of ABCcount
In 2023, two New York lawyers filed a brief citing cases that ChatGPT had invented, and were fined $5,000. The judge didn't punish them for using AI. He punished them for not checking, and for standing by the cases once the court asked. As he put it, the rules give lawyers “a gatekeeping role” to ensure their filings are accurate (Mata v. Avianca, as reported by LawNext).
Checking a citation takes about two minutes, most of it reading. Here's how, step by step, and how to check a whole brief at once.
Every case citation is an address. Take Brown v. Board of Education, 347 U.S. 483, 495 (1954):
| Brown v. Board of Education | Case name: the parties, as the court reported them |
| 347 | Volume of the reporter |
| U.S. | Reporter: here, United States Reports, the official Supreme Court reporter |
| 483 | First page of the opinion in that volume |
| 495 | Pinpoint: the page that says what you cite it for |
| (1954) | Year decided, and for lower courts the court as well, e.g. (11th Cir. 2019) |
Volume, reporter and first page find the case. The name, court and year confirm it's the right one. The pinpoint is where your point should be.
Look it up by the citation, not the name (30 seconds)
Search the volume, reporter and page, such as 347 U.S. 483, in CourtListener (free), Google Scholar’s case law search (free), or Westlaw or Lexis if you have them. Searching by name finds the real case even when your citation is wrong. Searching by citation tells you what is actually at that address.
Check the name matches what’s there (15 seconds)
The case at that volume and page must be the case your text names. A real citation with the wrong name is the hardest error to spot, because the citation itself checks out. "Smith v. Jones, 384 U.S. 436 (1966)" looks fine; 384 U.S. 436 is Miranda v. Arizona.
Check the court and year (15 seconds)
Both should match the opinion you found. A Fifth Circuit case cited as Eleventh Circuit, or a year a decade off, means the citation was copied from somewhere unreliable or was never real.
Open the opinion and find the pinpoint (About a minute)
Go to the pinpoint page and find the words or the holding you rely on. Invented quotes are the most common AI error after invented cases, and real cases are often cited for things they don’t say. No tool does this step for you.
Check it’s still good law (Depends on your tools)
A citator (Shepard’s, KeyCite or BCite) shows whether the case has been reversed, overruled or questioned. Free databases list later cases that cite it, which helps, but is not a substitute for a citator before you file.
AI tools don't produce obvious nonsense. They produce citations that look exactly like real ones. These are the signs worth a second look:
Errors don't only come from research. In one 2026 case, a lawyer checked every citation, then had an AI tool polish the brief, and the polish changed them: what happened in TOV Realty v. Suarez. Check again after any AI edit.
Check a whole brief at once
ABCcount's free Citation Checker does steps 1 to 3 for every citation in a brief. Paste the text or upload a .docx or PDF. It looks up each case citation in CourtListener, flags a real citation attached to the wrong case name, and checks federal regulations such as 40 CFR 110.3 against eCFR. You can download a record of what was checked.
It's a database lookup, not a verdict. “Found” means the case exists and the details match, not that it says what you cite it for. It isn't a citator, and “not found” means check by hand. Steps 4 and 5 still need you.
Open the Citation CheckerUsing AI to tidy a letter rather than a brief? These are the five things to check in an AI-edited legal letter.
Search the citation, such as 347 U.S. 483, in CourtListener or Google Scholar’s case law search. Check that the case at that address has the name, court and year in your text, then open the opinion and find the page you cite. Free tools don’t replace a citator for checking the case is still good law.
Lawyers in a New York federal case filed a brief citing cases ChatGPT had invented. On 22 June 2023 Judge P. Kevin Castel fined two lawyers and their firm $5,000. The judge said using AI wasn’t improper in itself; the sanctions followed their failure to check the cases and their standing by them after the court questioned them.
Yes. In federal court, signing a filing certifies its legal contentions are warranted by existing law (Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 11(b)(2)), and ABA Formal Opinion 512 says lawyers must check AI output they rely on. That holds when the AI only edited a draft you had already checked.
No. Free databases miss some very recent, unpublished and state cases. "Not found" means check it by hand, in Westlaw, Lexis or the court’s own records, before you rely on it or call it fake.
About two minutes a citation by hand. The ABCcount Citation Checker looks up every case citation in a pasted or uploaded brief at once and flags the ones to check by hand, so the time goes on steps 4 and 5, which need a person.
Sources: LawNext, “Court imposes sanctions on lawyers who filed bogus cases after relying on ChatGPT”, 22 June 2023; Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 11(b)(2); ABA Formal Opinion 512 (29 July 2024). Checked 16 November 2026 and rechecked every November. General information, not legal advice.